How Doubtful Investors Are Falling in Love With Stocks Again - OZY | A Modern Media Company

How Doubtful Investors Are Falling in Love With Stocks Again

How Doubtful Investors Are Falling in Love With Stocks Again

By Richard Henderson

Traders work at the New York Stock Exchange in New York, the United States.
SourceXinhua/ via Getty


“Fear of missing out” dominates as doubters turn into believers.

By Richard Henderson

  • When the markets started to rise amid the crisis, many investors remained bearish, worried the gains wouldn’t survive.
  • Now, with the market seemingly immune to the devastating economic situation around it, their faith is being restored.

The bumper run in the U.S. stock market is beginning to turn its doubters into believers, adding fresh thrust to a rally that has wrong-footed veteran investors, lured in retail traders and defied the dire economic outlook caused by the global pandemic.

The S&P 500 of U.S. blue chip stocks is up more than a third from its low two months ago, in the depths of the virus sell-off. On Wednesday, the benchmark closed above 3,000 points for the first time since early March, bringing the index to just 10 percent below the record high reached in February.

The rally has built a legion of skeptics who worry the market is being driven entirely by Federal Reserve stimulus and that bullish investors are too confident a vaccine will emerge to rekindle corporate profits. But now, even detractors are reluctantly joining the buying. 

“There’s an element of fear of missing out — FOMO — as investors start to look at the momentum,” says Emily Roland, co-chief investment strategist for John Hancock Investment Management in Boston. She likens the recent buying by the new believers to crossing a busy highway: “They are looking for an opening; they know it’s possible to get hurt, but they are just going for it.”

Gains are not confined to the United States. Led by the S&P 500, the Stoxx 600 and FTSE 100, the United Kingdom benchmark, are both up by around a quarter, while the Nikkei index of Japanese stocks has gained more than 30 percent since the rally began on March 23.

Rallies are also beginning to expand beyond the mega-cap tech stocks that have emerged as a haven for investors through the turbulence this year — a signal that a broader range of buyers is joining the stampede. 

My 10-year-old son asked me if he can open an Etrade account so he could buy Tesla stock

Emily Roland, co-chief investment strategist, John Hancock Investment Management

Cyclical stocks and small caps have enjoyed bumper gains over the past week as investors show new support for economically sensitive companies.

On Tuesday, bank stocks had their best day since early April, suggesting the rally can endure, says Mike Mullaney, director of global markets research for fund manager Boston Partners. “You can’t leave the financial sector in the dust and expect the rally will last — the banks are the backbone of the economy,” he says.

Rob Almeida, global investment strategist for MFS Investment Management in Boston, has maintained a bearish view through the rally, but says missing out on the gains has been painful. MFS has joined the rally cautiously, expanding its holdings of tech groups that it believes will prosper through and beyond the COVID-19 crisis, like payments groups and athletic apparel companies, as stuck-at-home professionals swap suits for sweatpants.

“What you’ve seen in the last few weeks is a tremendous amount of assumptions,” Almeida says. “I think the market is ahead of itself.”

The forward price/earnings multiple for the S&P 500 — a popular valuation measure — is now above 23, its highest since the early 2000s, according to Capital IQ.

A vaccine for the coronavirus may yet be several years away and top scientists have warned that the colder months in the U.S. and Europe may bring about fresh outbreaks that lead to more shutdowns, hampering a recovery.

So far, though, the sustained buying has proved doubters wrong. Two weeks ago, Stanley Druckenmiller, the hedge fund manager who helped George Soros break the Bank of England, said the reward for buying equities was “as bad as I’ve seen.” David Tepper, founder of Appaloosa Management, a U.S. hedge fund, echoed this view a day later. Since then, U.S. stocks have gained around 7 percent.

Critics have also warned that retail investors, lacking the hard-nosed analysis of Wall Street professionals, are backing the rally — potentially dangerously bidding up battered stocks.

Users of Robinhood, the stock trading app, have more than doubled their positions in companies in the Russell 3000 index of the biggest U.S- listed groups since the rally began, according to Morgan Stanley calculations. The 10 most popular stocks held by Robinhood users include American Airlines and Carnival, the cruise operator — two coronavirus-hit companies whose fortunes may not turn for some time.

Online trading and a “buy the dip” mentality have helped attract a new breed of retail investor, says Roland.

“My 10-year-old son asked me if he can open an Etrade account so he could buy Tesla stock,” she says. He had learned about fractional shares, which give investors the ability to buy a slice of a stock and would allow him to purchase a portion of the carmaker’s shares that currently trade at $820. “He only has $150 — it was his First Communion money.”

Steven DeSanctis, an equity analyst for Jefferies, says daily trading in small biotech stocks has climbed in recent weeks, often exceeding companies’ outstanding share count. He puts this down to active day trading, reminiscent of retail investors’ frothy buying of internet stocks during the dot-com boom.

“There’s a little of that euphoria in the market, which makes me nervous. You know how it ends — badly,” DeSanctis says.

Those priming for another big sell-off may have to wait. U.S. policymakers have indicated they are ready to expand the record amounts of fiscal and monetary support and all states are either relaxing their shutdowns or have reopened.

“I don’t think the market can get knocked down by much these days,” says Roland. “What we’ve seen is absolutely devastating — but markets seem entirely immune to it.”

By Richard Henderson

OZY partners with the U.K.'s Financial Times to bring you premium analysis and features. © The Financial Times Limited 2020.

Sign up for the weekly newsletter!

Related Stories